- '08 TN PG Tyler Cutter (Transferred to Lee University)
- '08 IL SF Carl Richard (LOI)
- '09 IN SF R.J. Mahurin (LOI)
- '08 NE SF Koang Doluony (Transferred to Nebraska-Omaha)
- '08 IN PG Rashad Reed (LOI)
- '08 CA C Josh Crawford (LOI)
- '07 IN SG Jake Kelly (LOI)
- '12 IN SF Rhett Smith (Transferred to Hillsdale)
- Where Are They Now: Trent Wurtz
- Where Are They Now: Djibril Kante
- Where Are They Now: Marcus Howard
- '10 WI PG Steve McWhorter (Transferred to Milwaukee)
- '09 IL SG Logan Eitel (LOI)
- '07 IL C Isiah Martin (LOI)
- '07 IA SG Jordan Printy (LOI)
- '07 IN SG Aaron Carter (LOI)
- '06 OH C Brant Leitnaker (LOI)
- '07 LA SG Dwayne Lathan (Transfer from Louisiana Tech)
- '06 IN PG Harry Marshall (LOI)
- Where Are They Now: Nate Green
- '10 TX C Myles Walker (LOI)
- Marico Stinson (Transfered to Kentucky Wesleyan)
- Lamar Lee to Indiana Tech
- '11 IN OL Zach Lewis (Indiana State Verbal)
- David Moss